devices(ubiquiti): the EdgeRouter Infinity was two models with two incompatible cablings #2183

Merged
jaylouisw merged 1 commit from catalogue/1119-1652 into main 2026-11-19 17:08:30 +00:00
Owner

Refs #130 - records a catalogue defect on this request's routed-lab path; it does not close it, because the Pro's census is still unpublished.

One box, two rows. The catalogue held the EdgeRouter Infinity twice:

row (main) model ports interface eth3 interface sfp3
er-8-xg.json ER-8-XG eth0, sfp1..sfp8 % Interface not found accepted
edgerouter-infinity.json EdgeRouter Infinity eth0, eth1..eth8 accepted % Interface not found

modelKey() normalises them to ubiquiti|er8xg and ubiquiti|edgerouterinfinity, so the duplicate gate never saw them: one router, two picker entries, two cablings that cannot talk to each other.

The names are printed, not conventional. QSG front-panel LED table: SFP+ (eth1-8), RJ45 (eth0); access section: "By default, eth1 is set up as a DHCP client, while eth0 is assigned a static IP address of 192.168.1.1". So sfp1..sfp8 named ports the device does not have.

probe (after merge) result
show interfaces eth0 1G + eth1-eth8 10G, 9 ports
interface eth1 / ip address dhcp Interface eth1 set to DHCP
interface sfp3 % Interface not found: sfp3 - the phantom spelling is gone

Fix. One row at devices/ubiquiti/er-8-xg.json: model ER-8-XG (what the datasheet and the store page print), alias EdgeRouter Infinity, vendor names eth0 + eth1..eth8, speedCaps [10,100,1000] on copper and 10G on the cages, capabilities unchanged. edgerouter-infinity.json deleted; its entry dropped from research/incoming/devices-routers-ent.json so a re-import cannot resurrect it. The RJ45 serial console is recorded in notes, not interfaces (docs/DEVICE_SCHEMA.md). No PoE is declared - the tech-spec table has no PoE row and the power rows are PSU-only (2x hot-swap 100 W).

Sources (all real documents, none the fallback):

  • datashape https://dl.ui.com/datasheets/edgemax/EdgeRouter_ER-8-XG_DS.pdf - 200, application/pdf, 5,606,800 B, 6 pp: "(8) 10G SFP+ Ports / (1) RJ45 Gigabit Ethernet Port / (1) RJ45 Serial Console Port", 80 Gbps line rate, 18 Mpps, 100 W.
  • QSG https://dl.ui.com/guides/edgemax/EdgeRouter_ER-8-XG_QSG.pdf - 200, 3,261,200 B: the eth0/eth1-8 labels above.
  • tech-spec https://techspecs.ui.com/uisp/wired/er-8-xg - 200, 583,121 B: management port + 9 data ports, 160 Gbps switching capacity.
  • store https://store.ui.com/us/en/products/er-8-xg - 200, 337,183 B - the SKU slug for the same box.

Trap recorded: EdgeRouter_Infinity_DS.pdf, guides/edgemax/EdgeRouter_Infinity_QSG.pdf, qs/ER-8-XG.pdf and ds/er-8-xg_ds.pdf all answer 200 with the 609,911-byte techspecs front page. The documents exist only under the SKU spelling.

Gates: syntax 460 OK; audit-port-types clean; audit-poe-budget 407 PSEs / 0 budget-without-PSE; audit-devices no hard defects; hardware invariants 26/0; doc-catalog-counts 43/43; importer dry run differs from main only by the removed duplicate (1188 -> 1187 scanned, nothing new added); run-tests 381 suites / 12,885 assertions / 0 failed. Counts regenerated: 2,355 models, 29,710 sockets, 972 shapes.

Refs #130 - records a catalogue defect on this request's routed-lab path; it does **not** close it, because the Pro's census is still unpublished. **One box, two rows.** The catalogue held the EdgeRouter Infinity twice: | row (main) | model | ports | `interface eth3` | `interface sfp3` | |---|---|---|---|---| | `er-8-xg.json` | `ER-8-XG` | eth0, sfp1..sfp8 | `% Interface not found` | accepted | | `edgerouter-infinity.json` | `EdgeRouter Infinity` | eth0, eth1..eth8 | accepted | `% Interface not found` | `modelKey()` normalises them to `ubiquiti|er8xg` and `ubiquiti|edgerouterinfinity`, so the duplicate gate never saw them: one router, two picker entries, two cablings that cannot talk to each other. **The names are printed, not conventional.** QSG front-panel LED table: `SFP+ (eth1-8)`, `RJ45 (eth0)`; access section: *"By default, eth1 is set up as a DHCP client, while eth0 is assigned a static IP address of 192.168.1.1"*. So `sfp1..sfp8` named ports the device does not have. | probe (after merge) | result | |---|---| | `show interfaces` | eth0 1G + eth1-eth8 10G, 9 ports | | `interface eth1` / `ip address dhcp` | `Interface eth1 set to DHCP` | | `interface sfp3` | `% Interface not found: sfp3` - the phantom spelling is gone | **Fix.** One row at `devices/ubiquiti/er-8-xg.json`: model `ER-8-XG` (what the datasheet and the store page print), alias `EdgeRouter Infinity`, vendor names eth0 + eth1..eth8, `speedCaps` [10,100,1000] on copper and 10G on the cages, capabilities unchanged. `edgerouter-infinity.json` deleted; its entry dropped from `research/incoming/devices-routers-ent.json` so a re-import cannot resurrect it. The RJ45 serial console is recorded in `notes`, not `interfaces` (`docs/DEVICE_SCHEMA.md`). No PoE is declared - the tech-spec table has no PoE row and the power rows are PSU-only (2x hot-swap 100 W). **Sources** (all real documents, none the fallback): - datashape `https://dl.ui.com/datasheets/edgemax/EdgeRouter_ER-8-XG_DS.pdf` - 200, application/pdf, 5,606,800 B, 6 pp: *"(8) 10G SFP+ Ports / (1) RJ45 Gigabit Ethernet Port / (1) RJ45 Serial Console Port"*, 80 Gbps line rate, 18 Mpps, 100 W. - QSG `https://dl.ui.com/guides/edgemax/EdgeRouter_ER-8-XG_QSG.pdf` - 200, 3,261,200 B: the eth0/eth1-8 labels above. - tech-spec `https://techspecs.ui.com/uisp/wired/er-8-xg` - 200, 583,121 B: management port + 9 data ports, 160 Gbps switching capacity. - store `https://store.ui.com/us/en/products/er-8-xg` - 200, 337,183 B - the SKU slug for the same box. **Trap recorded:** `EdgeRouter_Infinity_DS.pdf`, `guides/edgemax/EdgeRouter_Infinity_QSG.pdf`, `qs/ER-8-XG.pdf` and `ds/er-8-xg_ds.pdf` all answer 200 with the 609,911-byte techspecs front page. The documents exist only under the SKU spelling. **Gates:** syntax 460 OK; audit-port-types clean; audit-poe-budget 407 PSEs / 0 budget-without-PSE; audit-devices no hard defects; hardware invariants 26/0; doc-catalog-counts 43/43; importer dry run differs from main only by the removed duplicate (1188 -> 1187 scanned, nothing new added); run-tests 381 suites / 12,885 assertions / 0 failed. Counts regenerated: 2,355 models, 29,710 sockets, 972 shapes.
devices(ubiquiti): the EdgeRouter Infinity was two models with two incompatible cablings (refs #130)
All checks were successful
CI / Classify the change (pull_request) Successful in 15s
PR rebase / Rebase onto main and arm auto-merge (pull_request) Successful in 11s
CI / Server smoke test (pull_request) Successful in 10s
CI / Test (Node 22) (pull_request) Successful in 58s
CI / Test (Node 20) (pull_request) Successful in 59s
CI / Test (Node 18) (pull_request) Successful in 1m3s
CI / Docker build (pull_request) Successful in 26s
CI / Arm auto-merge (pull_request) Successful in 4s
15ed3ace17
The catalogue held one box twice. `devices/ubiquiti/er-8-xg.json` called it
`ER-8-XG` and named the cages `sfp1..sfp8`; `devices/ubiquiti/edgerouter-infinity.json`
called it `EdgeRouter Infinity` and named them `eth1..eth8`. `modelKey()` cannot
catch that pair - the strings normalise to `ubiquiti|er8xg` and
`ubiquiti|edgerouterinfinity` - so the picker offered one router as two models, and
a lab cabled through the first could not address the ports the second accepted
(`interface eth3` answered "not found" on one row and was accepted on the other).

The names are not a convention here, they are printed: the QSG front-panel table
labels the cages "SFP+ (eth1-8)" and the copper port "RJ45 (eth0)", and its access
section says eth1 is the default DHCP client while eth0 carries 192.168.1.1.

So the SKU row keeps the model the datasheet and the store page both print
(`ER-8-XG`), gains the product name as an alias, and takes the vendor's names
eth0 + eth1..eth8. The second file is deleted and its entry dropped from
research/incoming so a re-import cannot resurrect it. The serial console port is
recorded in notes, not interfaces, per docs/DEVICE_SCHEMA.md.

Sources: dl.ui.com/datasheets/edgemax/EdgeRouter_ER-8-XG_DS.pdf (200,
application/pdf, 5,606,800 B, 6 pp), dl.ui.com/guides/edgemax/EdgeRouter_ER-8-XG_QSG.pdf
(200, 3,261,200 B), techspecs.ui.com/uisp/wired/er-8-xg (200, 583,121 B). Four
plausible spellings (EdgeRouter_Infinity_DS.pdf, EdgeRouter_Infinity_QSG.pdf,
qs/ER-8-XG.pdf, ds/er-8-xg_ds.pdf) all answer 200 with the 609,911 B front-page
fallback; the note records that trap.

Catalogue counts regenerated (2,355 models / 29,710 sockets / 972 shapes).
forgejo-actions scheduled this pull request to auto merge when all checks succeed 2026-11-19 17:00:43 +00:00
jaylouisw deleted branch catalogue/1119-1652 2026-11-19 17:08:32 +00:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No reviewers
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
jaylouisw/packetforge!2183
No description provided.